Screen Printing Vs Plastisol Transfers

When I first started my Chaos Wear I didn’t know about plastosol transfers, my original plan was to use ‘inkjet transfers’ as my printing method, simply so that I could produce them as and when I needed them. Just like most start-up business owners I had this nagging voice in the back of my mind asking ‘what if it doesn’t work out?’, so I wanted to keep my costs to an absolute minimum. I bought a heat press and a vinyl cutter so I could contour cut. After literally months of not being able to get along with my cutter I decided to change my business model and outsource my printing, I figured a couple of benefits of this would be that the printing would be to a better standard if I left it to the professionals, any error would cost them and not me and I had more time to spend on actually running the business.

I then began looking into different modes of printing and screen printing seemed the best option. The biggest problem for me was that my designs were very colorful and detailed, and since screen printing is billed per color, it wasn’t looking good (I would very much advise you guys to pick your printing method before designing your shirts). The other problem was that I was offering my designs in 5 different sizes in mens, 4 sizes in womens, 5 sizes in hoodies and 4 sizes in kids, so for example if I wanted to order 5 of each type for 20 designs I would have ended up ordering 1800 garments in total! the nagging voice in the back of my head was ready to explode!

After doing some research I found out about plastisol transfers, for those of you who don’t know what plastisol transfers are, it is the same process and quality as screen printing, however, instead of printing directly onto the garment, the design is printed onto release paper and then is heat pressed on, below is a video of the process to help you get an idea of what is involved (the t-square it tool is helpful but not a necessity)

And it really is as simple as that! For me it was a no-brainer, it felt like ordering plastisol transfers was a much better idea as I didn’t need to buy tons of preprinted shirts, I could simply press as I sold, minimizing costs if the business didn’t work, the other benefit that really appealed to me was the fact that I was able to offer all shirt types; to me there was nothing worse than turning away a customer that wanted to buy a specific design in a certain size which was sold out whilst the other shirt sizes were overstocked. Another benefit of plastisol transfer printing is the ability to purchase ‘gang sheets’, this means putting several designs onto one sheet, for example if an a3 sized sheet costs $2.40, and you’re able to fit 3 designs on there, the cost of each design would be $0.80, so it can work out to be much much cheaper for some than screen printing depending on the design. Gang sheets would look something similar to this;

prison gang X lg Screen Printing Vs Plastisol Transfers

Remember my problem I told you about earlier about too many colors? Well I found out about a type of plastisol transfer/screen printing called ‘4 colour process’ which has the same price for 4 or 40 color designs and tackles gradients and shading well, I have even seen US companies offer quantities starting from 8 pieces!

However, screen printing directly onto shirts also has it’s advantages, as many screen printers do not offer printing as plastisol transfers as a service, it may be that you are able to negotiate a better price, you could also get a better price if your screen printer gets good discounts for purchasing large amounts of blank garments, another benefit is that you get the complete product, so that you are spared from any wastage due to errors whilst pressing. Outsourcing your printing completely would also spare you the cost of purchasing ‘heat press’ machine that range from around $200-$1000+.

whichever method you choose, I highly recommend that you request samples from potential suppliers and give repeat test washes to ensure the quality of the garments and also remember to include the cost of screen charges to the cost of the transfers when comparing prices of different companies.

I wish good luck to you all in whichever method you decide to take

This post was written by:
Ruchi the owner of Chaos Wear, a funny t-shirt company in the UK!

If you need an e-commerce site Shopify is perfect for beginners and experts alike. You don't need to have any technical or design experience to easily create a beautiful online store. Simply choose a stylish ecommerce website design, easily customize your online store, add products, and you're pretty much ready to accept payments. Plans start at $14 and comes with a free no risk 30 day trial period. Click here to create your store now. Also check out our in depth review of Shopify here and see why Shopify is our number 1 recommended shop for clothing companies.


Connect with us

Email Newsletter

Like this post? Sign up to receive email updates and get the latest posts from How to start a clothing company.

  • usman

    that link for the list of plastisol printing companies is not working

  • http://www.defunkte.es DefunktOne

    Thanks for the tip. Pre-ordering batches gets pretty darn expensive!!!

  • steve a

    Thanks for this post im in the printing process of my own designs and i have people that want what i make but i don't have every design printed this sound like a great alternative to start up with until the money starts flowing in.

  • http://twitter.com/eacisdopeness Eduardo Aguilar

    what do you think about water based inks and do you know any good water based shirt printers??

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_53SOADIK36JQTJIOMKQ52BPD3Y Patrick W

    i don't know where to post all my questions: What do you call the paper transfer that you use for the printer, Any inkjet printer works? Do you need special ink or regular printer ink works? instead of a heat press, Can i use a regular iron for press? How much money do I need for start up. Do i need a bank loan, Do i need a EIn or business license if I'm opening up a store? but just sell it on the internet?

  • Myklnj

    Hello,

    First time poster, long time lurker…lol.

    I wonder if you could speak to the cost of these two methods.

    If plastisol is the same as screenprinting with the exception that one is printed to a tee and another to transfer paper, is cost the only difference.

    Understanding that certain transfers may not hold up in the wash, is the print quality about the same in general?

    I am currently working on a line and working on a business/action plan and am at a crossroad as to whether to outsource to a plastisol printer and press myself or to outsource the whole deal.

    Thanks in advance for any insight you can offer.

    Mykl

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000038402403 Andy Whipyoass Witabelt

    Hey, Im using inkjet printing method for my shirts and the printing is fine. The only problem is that the transfers dont stay on the t-shirts for more than a few hours because their corners start comming off. I need some help. I dont know whether I should start using plastisol transfers because I dont know if they will stick really good. Or if i should get some glue or something to make the screen printing more sticky so it can stay on the t-shirts. PLEASE HELP ME!

  • Piers

    hey, what screen printer website are you using ?

  • http://farahfashionsnyc.blogspot.com/ Farah Fashions NYC

    i started my tshirt business last feb 2014. i researched about plastisol transfer. I think this is the cost effective method for me. I also bought heat press from ebay. After some trial i was able to find the perfect temperature for heat press. the quality of the shirt is good. I sold my shirt on bazaars. i haven’t sell anything through my on-line website so i have to close it for a while and study about my next plan.